To use hand sanitizers, or stick to conventional soap and water? – That is the question!
The debate about hand sanitizers is strong. It is true that hand sanitizers are convenient and efficient at eliminating certain types of germs. However, it is also true that they cannot replace the effects soap and water yield. So, which side do you stand on?
Before you proceed to answer, take note that one of the two selections are not entirely great for our health. Below are some things you should know about how hand sanitizers would affect us.
Cannot Replace Washing Hands
As shared by the Capital Region Board of Cooperative Educational Services (BOCES), using hand sanitizers should not be seen as an act to replace hand washing. If hands have visible dirt, these sanitizers don’t exactly remove it very well.
Selected Protection
Although sanitizers eliminate bacteria and give users an extra layer of protection, experts believe that they are less helpful in reducing the incidence of some of the more dreaded illnesses, such as cold and the stomach bug.
This is proven via a study conducted by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) – results showed that those who used hand sanitizers over soap and water for routine hand hygiene were six times more likely to experience a stomach flu outbreak.
Reduced Muscle Strength
Most hand sanitizers contain triclosan, and researches have shown that the said ingredient holds potential to reduce muscle strength, as well as disrupting the immune and endocrine system. Thus, it makes us weaker and more prone to diseases.
Potentially Kills Of Good Bacteria
Antibacterial agents will kill most germs on contact. This is good, but the remaining small percentage of germs that survive might lead to the development of resistant bacteria. And these bacteria might kill off the friendly bugs that protect us from infection.
Highly Flammable
The recommended percentage of alcohol in hand sanitizer to make them effective is 60% to 90%. This makes it highly flammable as well as toxic to small children if ingested.
Verdict: The answer to the question of ‘Hand Sanitizers vs. Soap and Water’ seems pretty obvious to us. While we apologize for bursting the bubbles of those who prefer hand sanitizers, it should be known that washing our hands with plain ol’ soap and water remains the best way to keep them clean and prevent the spread of germs.
Information Sources: Whole Health Insider, CNN, Livestrong